Statements
A report aired on Imedis
Kvira program of Imedi TV on 26 July triggered hot discussions lately. The
report was about a fact of domestic violence against a woman and touched on the
problem related to the phenomenon called "virginity institute.” Even though the
intention of presenters of the program to cover the incident as a problem was
obvious both at the beginning and the end of the material, the report was
revictimizing the victim of domestic violence and further strengthening
damaging stereotypes.
Professional standards of journalism requires from
journalists to respect dignity and private life and space of a person and
prohibits them to manipulate with emotions and sentiments. In this report, the
private space of the victim woman was crudely violated; the audience learned
not only about her name and living place but also about such personal details
as her monthly cycle, opinion of expertise about her virginity, the location of
sexual intercourse and sexual abuse – close ups of the bed. All this smacked of
the attempt to create vulgar sensation rather than realistically represent a
deep and serious problem.
Article 35.6 of the Code of Conduct for Broadcasters allows
the infringement of privacy only if it "is aimed at protecting legitimate
rights of the public, is the only proportionate means to this end and the
protected good outweighs potential harm.” The above mentioned report, however,
cannot be considered a proportionate means to the end. Opening up a public
discussion about sexual control and oppression of women does not outweigh that
harm which the woman identified in the report may sustain as a result of
repressive and stereotyped attitudes existing in our society. Even in the case
when a consent is obtained on the identification of a victim, journalists bear
social responsibility to realize the pressure which their respondent may find
herself under due to opinions that dominate society.
True, a journalist cannot ignore a fact of violence as a
piece of news, but by showing a big picture instead of focusing on a single
individual, a journalist may present the problem from the human rights
perspective and in legal context.
In a cultural setting in which women often become victims of
sexist attitudes and stereotypes existing in society, media may hugely
contribute to the fight against injustice and women’s oppression by deep and
thorough coverage of a problem and triggering a serious discussion.
For media as an influential institution to realize its
responsibility to society, it is important, when covering facts of violence
against women, to reflect those approaches which are provided in
recommendations of UNESCO and other international organizations. We call on
media outlets:
• To refrain from revictimization of people when covering
acts of violence against women;
• To be oriented on a survived victim, respect her feelings
and minimize potential harm;
• To question attempts of presenting the act of violence as
something natural and a matter of honor;
• To help audience understand a broader context in terms of
human rights and legal aspect;
• To be consistent in reporting such accidents both in
covering the entire legal actions and victims’ attempts to overcome a post-traumatic
period.
We, Women’s Movement and representatives of non-governmental
organizations express our readiness to organize a broad and open discussion
with the involvement of media professionals. We believe that consensus must be
achieved on those values and standards which are oriented on promoting gender
equality and respect of individual’s personal life.
Women’s Movement
Media Development Foundation - MDF
Sapari
Georgian Democracy Initiative - GDI
Tolerance and Diversity Institute - TDI
Human Rights Education and Monitoring Center - EMC
Charter of Journalistic Ethics
Citizen Journalism Club
Media Club
Georgian Association of Regional Broadcasters
Identoba
Black and Baltic Sea Alliance - Georgia
Studiomobile – Accent on Movement
Women’s Initiative for Equality
Women’s Fund in Georgia
Georgian Centre for Psychosocial and Medical Rehabilitation of Torture
Victims - GCRT
Women’s Information Center
Institute for Development of Freedom of Information IDFI
Institute of Nonviolent Communication
Article 42 of Constitution
Georgian Institute of Psychotrauma